> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://thegreekfiles.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Why an Athenian pot in a Nubian pyramid shows Persians winning: a 2026 study points to merchants
- URL: https://thegreekfiles.com/sotades-amazon-rhyton-persians-greeks-nubia-merchants/
- Published: 2026-11-10T07:30:55.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-10T07:30:55.000Z
- Description: An Athenian vase found at Meroe shows Persians beating Greeks. Henry Colburn's 2026 paper argues merchants, not a royal gift or special order, explain it.
- Author: J E Cowie
- Tags: News

![Map showing where Meroë is](https://thegreekfiles.com/content/images/2026/11/map_mero.jpg)

Meroë, River Nile, Sudan

## A pot in a looted pyramid

In January 1921, the archaeologist George Reisner found an Athenian drinking vessel in the South Cemetery at Meroe, at the base of a pyramid now designated Beg. S 24\. Reisner wrote that plunderers had taken it from the burial chamber of the little prince (or princess) to whom the tomb belonged, and that it was left "practically on the surface" under driftsand that also held the missing parts in minute fragments. The vessel is a rhyton, and it carries the signature of the Athenian potter Sotades.

The pyramid belongs to a group of elite tombs built in the generations before the first royal burial at Meroe, that of Arkamani I, around 270 BCE. On the basis of tomb typology, location and its relationship to other structures, Beg. S 24 dates to the first half of the fourth century. Henry P. Colburn of Bryn Mawr College examines the rhyton in a paper in *Greece & Rome*, published online on 10 March 2026 and in the April 2026 issue.

## What the vessel looks like

The rhyton stands thirty-four centimetres high on a rectangular base measuring twenty-eight by ten centimetres. It is essentially a statuette of a mounted Amazon with a red-figure cup emerging from her back. Her Attic helmet was originally painted red, with a white horsehair crest, and she wears a blue long-sleeved tunic decorated with red dots and purple trousers, now faded to pink. On the base, an incised signature reads ‘Sotades made \[me\]’.

The cup is the startling part: to the Amazon's left a mounted Persian spears a fallen Greek, and to her right a Greek carrying a shield retreats from a Persian. The Persian's shield bears a dog with its tail between its legs. The vessel is now in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, as 21.2286.

## A date, and a signature that proves less than it seems

Since Ashton Sanborn's first study in 1930, the rhyton has generally been dated to about 440 BCE. Colburn adds a caution about the signature: as a guide to date it is not definitive, and at best it indicates that the rhyton is no earlier than the middle of the fifth century. He also notes that a potter's signature does not guarantee he made the piece, so the rhyton may have been made by someone else using a mould made by Sotades.

## Persians winning is rare on Athenian pottery

According to Colburn, images of non-Greeks defeating Greeks on Attic pottery are quite rare, and only two examples of victorious Persians are known. The other is a fragmentary camel-shaped rhyton in the Louvre, dated about 460 to 450 BCE, which also has a rectangular base and a signature of Sotades. Colburn says the Amazon rhyton's shape alludes to Achaemenid metal rhyta, and that the Amazon's long-sleeved tunic and trousers make the link with Persians explicit. In his reading, the vessel is an adaptation of an Achaemenid metal rhyton, one that builds on a Persian prototype but adapts it to Greek conventions and expectations.

The closest metal parallel he names is a silver horn-shaped rhyton found in 1968 at Erebuni, modern Yerevan, in Armenia, with a horse-and-rider protome. A second possible parallel is a bronze and copper rhyton acquired by Sir Aurel Stein in the Gilgit Agency of the British Raj, now Gilgit-Baltistan, Pakistan.

## Not a gift, not a special order

Because of its strange form and iconography, the rhyton has not played a significant role in studies of trade or intercultural interaction, even though its archaeological provenance is secure. Colburn argues that these same features are best explained by a feedback loop of information between Sotades and his Persian customers, relayed by merchants. He says commissioning evidence for Athenian pottery is equivocal at best and usually a matter of conjecture. On the diplomatic-gift idea, he notes that the tomb predates the first royal burial at Meroe by about a century, and that ceramic is a very unlikely material for a Persian royal gift.

Colburn calls the evidence that the Amazon and camel rhyta were intended for a Persian audience quite strong, but says such interpretations face two difficulties: how Sotades could have known about his Persian customers, or how anyone in Egypt could have commissioned a vessel from him, and the fact that the depictions of Persians on the two rhyta are heavily stereotyped. Colburn proposes that merchants carried information about foreign customers back to Athenian workshops, and that this information was distorted, translated and perhaps even manipulated along the way. That, he suggests, helped give the rhyton its unusual appearance.

## The road through Egypt

Egypt was an Achaemenid satrapy between 526 and 404 BCE, and Colburn writes that most Persian customers probably lived in Memphis, the seat of the Achaemenid satrap and the administrative centre of the province. Colburn notes that Attic red-figure sherds have been excavated in the enclosure around the Palace of Apries, the headquarters of the satrap. He also cites an Aramaic document found at Elephantine that lists the arrivals and departures of Greek and Levantine ships at an unnamed Egyptian port in 475 BCE, or possibly 454; the document, he writes, clearly shows the importation of pottery to Egypt by Greeks as part of mixed cargoes. Citing Alain Bresson, he says the pottery did not itself motivate the trade between Egypt and Athens, being what Bresson calls a ‘free rider’.

GreekReporter reports that Colburn suggests the rhyton was probably bought in Egypt before eventually reaching Meroe. In the paper's conclusion, Colburn writes that the link between Sotades and his Persian customers in Egypt was “weak yet persistent”, and its abstract calls the rhyton the culmination of a sustained period of tenuous yet persistent links between Sotades' workshop in Athens and Persians living in Egypt.

The appeal of this reading is that it treats an object once regarded as a curiosity not as a special circumstance but as the product of sustained commercial contact. It is one scholar's proposal, not a settled result, and the paper itself names scholars who dissent from the view that these rhyta were made for export to the Persian empire.

## Sources

cambridge.org (n.d.) 'Sotades' Amazon Rhyton: A Case Study in Cross-Cultural Connectivity\*', cambridge.org, available at: [https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/A17A7E6E69ECFB063209133CDCEA529C/S0017383525100533a.pdf/sotades-amazon-rhyton-a-case-study-in-cross-cultural-connectivity.pdf](https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/A17A7E6E69ECFB063209133CDCEA529C/S0017383525100533a.pdf/sotades-amazon-rhyton-a-case-study-in-cross-cultural-connectivity.pdf?ref=thegreekfiles.com) (Accessed: 10 November 2026).

Colburn, H. P. (2026) 'SOTADES’ AMAZON RHYTON: A CASE STUDY IN CROSS-CULTURAL CONNECTIVITY', Cambridge Core, 10 March 2026, available at: [https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/greece-and-rome/article/sotades-amazon-rhyton-a-case-study-in-crosscultural-connectivity/A17A7E6E69ECFB063209133CDCEA529C](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/greece-and-rome/article/sotades-amazon-rhyton-a-case-study-in-crosscultural-connectivity/A17A7E6E69ECFB063209133CDCEA529C?ref=thegreekfiles.com) (Accessed: 10 November 2026).

Moeed, A. (2026) 'Greek Vase Discovered in Nubian Tomb Shows a Persian Warrior Spearing a Fallen Greek', GreekReporter.com, 7 November 2026, available at: [https://greekreporter.com/2026/11/07/vase-discovered-nubian-tomb-shows-persian-warrior-spearing-fallen-greek/](https://greekreporter.com/2026/11/07/vase-discovered-nubian-tomb-shows-persian-warrior-spearing-fallen-greek/?ref=thegreekfiles.com) (Accessed: 10 November 2026).

## Picture credits

- Top picture: Meroe's South Cemetery, where Reisner found the rhyton in 1921\. Image: Pyramids of the Meroe South Cemetery: David Stanley, [CC BY 2.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/?ref=thegreekfiles.com), via [Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:South%5FCemetery%5Fat%5FBegrawiya%5F%288650053221%29.jpg?ref=thegreekfiles.com)
- Map: drawn from [Natural Earth](https://www.naturalearthdata.com/?ref=thegreekfiles.com) (public domain) and [Wikidata](https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q5780?ref=thegreekfiles.com).